Find out more about this
Gesmer Updegrove has represented more than 184 standards consortia and open source foundations, including:
View Full Client List
Useful Links

Press Center Sitemap


Text Size:
Default  Large

RSS Feeds

Bookmark and Share

Standards <Meta>Library

Litigation & Legal Issues

Intellectual Property Rights (see also separate category of the same name)

(Select a New Topic or Category)

Title: "Recurring Themes on Reasonable Royalties in Recent IP United States Damage Cases"
Authors: Elizabeth Bailey
Alan Cox
Gregory Leonard
Source: NERA Economic Consulting
Publication Date: June 1 2011
Free/Fee: Free Access
Reads: 1149
Abstract: A source of considerable concern for companies selling products in the United States is the possibility of being sued for patent infringement in a US court. A finding of infringement of a valid US patent can lead to an award of monetary damages, either lost profits or a reasonable royalty, or a combination of the two. Historically, courts often have been willing to permit expert testimony on damages based on methodologies that had little or no rational, scientific, or business basis. However, four recent cases in the US are indicative of the trend toward higher standards for damage calculation: Lucent Technologies, Inc., v. Gateway, Inc. et al., i4i Limited Partnership v. Microsoft Corporation, Cornell University v. Hewlett-Packard Company, and Uniloc USA, Inc. et al. v. Microsoft Corporation. The Cornell case is a lower court case that was presided over by Chief Judge Rader of the CAFC. All the others were decided by panels of the CAFC judges on appeal from lower courts. This NERA paper describes some of the economic themes that have emerged from these cases. The authors note that litigants in patent cases in the US will need to pay attention to the heightened standards for damage awards when formulating their damage cases. Defendants, in particular, may want to address economically unsound damage claims based on the opinions of the CAFC in these four cases.
Link: Full Text